Nominations Cleanup and Questions

[pumpkinkingmod]

Tagset.

Most nominations have been processed. Questions below.

Nominations Awaiting Approval: Dark Souls (Video Games), Fruits Basket, Jem and the Holograms - All Media Types, The Little Mermaid (1989), Naruto/Dreaming of Sunshine, Star Wars - All Media Types



- Dark Souls (Video Games)
Dark Sun Gwyndolin
Lorian Elder Prince
Lothric Younger Prince
Solaire of Astora
Sulyvahn the Tyrant

Dark Souls I is already in the tagset. Is that part of the same series? Please pick a specific game.

- Fruits Basket
Manabe Kakeru
Sohma Yuki

Fruits Basket - Takaya Natsuki (Manga) is already a fandom in the tagset. Please pick a specific Fruits Basket for these characters.

- Jem and the Holograms - All Media Types
Ingrid "Minx" Kruger
Phoebe "Rapture" Ashe
Rory "Riot" Llewelyn
The Holograms (Jem and the Holograms)
The Misfits (Jem & the Holograms)
The Stingers (Jem and the Holograms)

Jem and the Holograms (Cartoon) is already a fandom in the tagset. Please pick a specific Jem fandom for these characters.

- The Little Mermaid (1989)
Vanessa (The Little Mermaid 1989)

Is this a separate character from Ursula?

- Naruto/Dreaming of Sunshine
Hyuuga Amano
Nara Kofuku
Nara Shikako
Uchiha Sasuke
Uchiha Shisui
Uchiha Uzume

Are these meant for Naruto or Dreaming of Sunshine? They appear nominated under Naruto.

- Star Wars - All Media Types
Jagged Fel
Jaina Solo
Mara Jade
Zekk (Star Wars)

Star Wars is already broken up into various fandoms. Which books or comics do you want these characters to be in, nominator?


Duplicate Fandoms In the Tagset: Evil Dead, Hollow Knight, Kamen Rider W, Psych, Spiritfarer



- Evil Dead is in the tagset twice, as follows:
Evil Dead - All Media Types
Annie Knowby (Evil Dead - All Media Types)
Ash Williams (Evil Dead - All Media Types)
Bobbie Jo (Evil Dead - All Media Types)
Cheryl Williams (Evil Dead - All Media Types)
Deadite Tree (Evil Dead - All Media Types)
Linda (Evil Dead - All Media Types)
Scotty (Evil Dead - All Media Types)
Sheila (Evil Dead - All Media Types)
Shelly (Evil Dead - All Media Types)
Wiseman (Evil Dead - All Media Types)

Evil Dead (Movies)
Annie Knowby (Evil Dead Movies)
Ash Williams (Evil Dead Movies)
Cheryl Williams (Evil Dead Movies)
Linda (Evil Dead Movies)
Scotty (Evil Dead Movies)
Sheila (Evil Dead Movies)

What do nominators prefer?

- Hollow Knight is in the tagset twice, as follows:
Hollow Knight (Video Game)
Herrah the Beast (Hollow Knight)
Hornet (Hollow Knight)
The Knight (Hollow Knight)
The Last Stag (Hollow Knight)
Myla (Hollow Knight)
Quirrel (Hollow Knight)

Hollow Knight (Video Games)
Grimm (Hollow Knight)
Grimmchild (Hollow Knight)
Herrah the Beast (Hollow Knight)
The Hollow Knight | Pure Vessel (Hollow Knight)
Hornet (Hollow Knight)
The Knight (Hollow Knight)
The Last Stag (Hollow Knight)
Myla (Hollow Knight)
Quirrel (Hollow Knight)
Zote the Mighty (Hollow Knight)

Which fandom name do nominators prefer?

- Kamen Rider W is in the tagset twice, as follows:
Kamen Rider W
Philip (Kamen Rider W)

Kamen Rider W (Double)
Hidari Shoutarou (Kamen Rider W)
Narumi Akiko (Kamen Rider W)
Sonozaki Saeko (Kamen Rider W)
Sonozaki Wakana (Kamen Rider W)
Sudou Kirihiko (Kamen Rider W)
Terui Haruna (Kamen Rider W)
Terui Ryu (Kamen Rider W)

Which fandom name do nominators prefer?

- Psych is in the tagset twice, as follows:
Psych
Burton 'Gus' Guster (Psych)
Buzz McNab (Psych)
Carlton Lassiter (Psych)
Henry Spencer (Psych)
Juliet O'Hara (Psych)
Karen Vick (Psych)
Shawn Spencer (Psych)
Woody the Coroner (Psych)

Psych (TV 2006)
Barbara Dunlap (Psych)
Carlton Lassiter's Father (Psych)
Joy Guster (Psych)
Lucinda Barry (Psych)
Madeleine Spencer (Psych)
Mona Lassiter (Psych)
Karen Vick (Psych)
Iris Vick (Psych)
Jack Spencer (Psych)
Victoria Lassiter (Psych)

Which fandom name do nominators prefer?

- Spiritfarer is in the tagset twice, as follows:
Spiritfarer (Video Game)
Alice (Spiritfarer)
Atul (Spiritfarer)
Daffodil (Spiritfarer)
Stanley (Spiritfarer)
Stella (Spiritfarer)
Summer (Spiritfarer)

Spiritfarer (Video Games)
Albert (Spiritfarer)
Astrid (Spiritfarer)
Buck (Spiritfarer)
Charon (Spiritfarer)
Francis (Spiritfarer)
Gustav (Spiritfarer)

Which fandom name do nominators prefer?


If there are any duplicates, wandering tags, or other things not mentioned here, please leave a comment on this post.

Comments

[sheliak]

Not the nominator, but the only characters from the Naruto/DOS set who appear in Naruto canon are Uchiha Sasuke and Uchiha Shisui; the rest (Hyuuga Amano, Nara Kofuku, Nara Shikako, and Uchiha Uzume) exist only in Dreaming of Sunshine.

(Incidentally, Sasuke and Shisui appear to already be in the tagset already under both fandoms!)

I wouldn't be surprised if someone tried to nominate Dreaming of Sunshine but used the version of the tag that's been synned to Naruto--I think that's happened to me in the past.

[sheliak]

Nara Shikako (Dreaming of Sunshine) is also showing up under Naruto

Morgan le Fay (Arthurian Mythology) is showing up under The Squire's Tales Series - Gerald Morris

Several characters from Vampire: The Masquerade: Bloodlines are also showing up under Vampire: The Masquerade
Deb (Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines)
Fledgling (Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines)
Mercurio (Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines)
Pisha (Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines)
Sire (Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines)

Some characters from Warhammer 40k (Novels) are also showing up under Warhammer 40.000--everything under Novels is meant to be there; no idea if they were also nominated for the other subfandom.
Angron (WH40k)
Fulgrim (WH40K)
Khârn (WH40k)
Konrad Curze (WH40K)
Magnus (WH40k)
Mortarion (WH40k)
Perturabo (WH40k)
Sanguinius (WH40k)

Unassociated characters:
Devon Adair (Earth 2 1994)
John Danziger (Earth 2 1994)
True Danziger (Earth 2 1994)

[siver]

A friend and I were the nominators for Spiritfarer and we both thought we were going with the standard but neither of us care one way or another. I guess Spiritfarer(Video Games)?

[(Anonymous)]

Hi! I am not sure if this is possible and if not, I understand completely, but I forgot noms closed yesterday and I had wanted to add a single character. If you can, do you mind adding Victor Pascow to Pet Sematary - Stephen King? Thank you!

[alana_exchange]

Dark Souls is a series of three games; Gwyndolin appears in both DS1 and DS3, Solaire only appears in DS1, and the other nominated characters appear only in DS3.

I'm totally fine with splitting the characters up into Dark Souls 1 and Dark Souls 3 as long as Gwyndolin ends up in both sets somehow!

[(Anonymous)]

Not the nominator, but from what I've seen Vanessa (Ursula's identity when she's transformed into a human) is normally considered a separate character for fic and exchange purposes, since people are likely to want very different things if they ask for one versus the other. Vanessa isn't even synned to Ursula on AO3, if it matters.

[alana_exchange]

Oh also I'm a Hollow Knight nominator and i have no actual preference lmao, whichever is canon for the archive is good for me unless another HK person swings in with a stronger opinion

[shinon]

I am also a Hollow Knight nominator and I also have no strong feelings, for whatever that's worth! It looks like "Hollow Knight (Video Games)" is the canonical tag.

[shadaras]

As someone else who nommed a character for Spiritfarer (and maybe overlapped with yours?), I also don't care? Whichever one is easiest for mods.

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicates in Higurashi no Naku Koro ni | Higurashi When They Cry:

Houjou Satoshi (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni | Higurashi When They Cry)
Houjou Satoshi (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni)

Ryuuguu Rena (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni | Higurashi When They Cry)
Ryuuguu Rena (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni)

Sonozaki Shion (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni | Higurashi When They Cry)
Sonozaki Shion (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni)

Takano Miyo (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni | Higurashi When They Cry)
Takano Miyo (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni)

[philstar22]

I was the Star Wars nominator. And sorry, I'm new, and didn't realize you do Star Wars by separate books. I was thinking generalized Legends. But I guess I can put them as Mara in Specter of the Past/Visions of the Future duology books era (I'm fine with her in any book era she's in, though, as long as Luke is there too) and Jaina, Zekk, and Jagged as New Jedi Order era (want those three together).

[(Anonymous)]

More duplicates for BoTB’s!

Breaking the Habit - Linkin Park (0)
Breaking the Habit - Linkin Park (Song) (0)

Everybody Wants to Rule the World - Lorde (Song) (0) <- Correct
Everybody Wants to Rule to World - Lorde (Song) (0) <- Incorrect

Nicotine - Panic! at the Disco (0)
Nicotine - Panic! at the Disco (Song) (0)

Seven Devils - Florence + the Machine (0)
Seven Devils - Florence and the Machine (0)

[(Anonymous)]

Typo in one of the nominations under uncategorozed fandom.

For the newly released “ Marvel's Avengers (Video Game 2020)“ fandom:

Tony Stark (Avenbers VG 2020)

Needs to be:

Tony Stark (Avengers VG 2020)

[(Anonymous)]

Psych (TV) nominator here. Given the choice, I always go with the disambiguated option. Because you never know when you're going to run into a Forever or New Amsterdam situation.

[bring_me_sugar]

Second Evil Dead nominator here - all of those characters appear in the movie canon, so I'm thinking the Wiseman, Bobbie Jo, Deadite Tree and Shelley can all be grouped under Movies unless the other nominator objects. There is a comic book series where all of the characters appear and Cheryl and Ash appear in Ash Vs Evil Dead, but both have their own, individualized tags on the archive. The movie's video game canons only share Ash as a uniting character.

[(Anonymous)]

Different nominator here - I'm not positive, but I think I was the one to nominate the Psych nomination for the eternal tagset last round when people were helping move over nominations from older tagsets. (I remember checking old tagsets for character lists, at least!) I would have nominated it as it was in past tagsets, but I have no objections to the disambiguated version. As you say, it's always best to keep things as clear as possible.

[(Anonymous)]

Vanessa nominator and this is what I had in mind making the nomination!

[(Anonymous)]

I didn't nominate Spiritfarer but there's only one installment in that series so 'Spiritfarer (Video Game)' is more accurate.

[pumpkinkingmod]

Thank you! I will accept it as is.

[pumpkinkingmod]

Thank you! I will accept it as is.

[pumpkinkingmod]

Thank you. That is the one now in the tagset.

[pumpkinkingmod]

Thank you! I have gone with the canonical.

[pumpkinkingmod]

Thank you! I have gone with the canonical, "Hollow Knight (Video Games)."

[pumpkinkingmod]

Thank you! I have gone with "Spiritfarer(Video Game)," as there are two works under it on AO3.

[pumpkinkingmod]

Thank you! I have gone with "Spiritfarer(Video Game)," as there are two works under it on AO3.