Trick or Treat Exchange

I didn't participate this year thanks to the change in matching, so if you're interested in the opinions of past recipients as well as recipients from this year when making your decision, I'd like to reiterate my earlier comment that I would strongly prefer a return to character matching. While I previously thought I'd probably be back either way once the disappointment had a chance to fade, at this point I'm honestly not sure I will if the change is permanent.