This is the general schedule & informational post.
General Links
2026 Collection
2026 Tagset
Revised 2026 Schedule
Sept 1 – Nominations Open
Sept 8 – Nominations Close
Sept 11 – Sign-Ups Open
Sept 18 – Sign-Ups Close
October 24 – Assignments Due
November 21 – Gift Reveals (16:59 UTC)
November 28 – Creator Reveals (16:59 UTC)
All times are 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT) unless otherwise specified.
The Basics
Trick or Treat is an exchange in the style of exchanges like Yuletide or Chocolate Box. It is inspired by a real world holiday, but you do not need to celebrate Halloween to participate in this exchange.
Each participant will receive at least one gift. The gift will be a trick or a treat, and gift minimums are 300 words for fic or a nice sketch for art. A trick should be more horror, occult, supernatural, or scary. A treat should be more sweet, sexy, or fluffy. These are a bit vague to give the writer/artist room for how they interpret trick or treat.
Participants must be 18 years or older.
( Read more... )
Please note the time-change on reveals!
AO3 returns! New Halloween date!
Nov. 15th, 2026 06:11 pmAO3 has returned! Which means Halloween is back on the calendar. Here are the new relevant dates:
I hope everyone is excited to celebrate New Halloween with piles of tricks and treats! The end of the longest Trick or Treat ever is in sight :)
See the OTW Status Page for official details regarding AO3's return.
- Pinch hits are due Thursday, Nov 19, 17:59 UTC (12:59 PM EST)
- Work reveals AKA New Halloween will be Saturday, Nov 21, 16:59 UTC (11:59 AM EST)
- Creator reveals will be Saturday, Nov 28, 16:59 UTC (11:59 AM EST)
I hope everyone is excited to celebrate New Halloween with piles of tricks and treats! The end of the longest Trick or Treat ever is in sight :)
See the OTW Status Page for official details regarding AO3's return.
Hello, Trick or Treaters! Unfortunately AO3 is still undergoing maintenance. You can find updates at the OTW Status page here.
Since we'll need a few days of functional archive to get pinch hits posted and confirm everything is in, that means we're not going to make the revised schedule.
In lieu of further rolling rescheduling, I'll update again no later than November 17, a week from today, with either a new schedule or a "nope, still down," as needed.
Good news: all pinch hits have been claimed!
"It is what it is" news: I unfortunately did not schedule "check Trick or Treat emails" into my November, so please be patient with any delayed mod email replies.
I also can't pass along recipient questions while the archive is down, so please use your best judgment for treat creation.
Since we'll need a few days of functional archive to get pinch hits posted and confirm everything is in, that means we're not going to make the revised schedule.
In lieu of further rolling rescheduling, I'll update again no later than November 17, a week from today, with either a new schedule or a "nope, still down," as needed.
Good news: all pinch hits have been claimed!
"It is what it is" news: I unfortunately did not schedule "check Trick or Treat emails" into my November, so please be patient with any delayed mod email replies.
I also can't pass along recipient questions while the archive is down, so please use your best judgment for treat creation.
[See previous post for details on our AO3 outage delay]
Your keen detective work leads you through the quaint pumpkin patches and spooky murder sheds of Halloweenland, to the (insert ominous music) graaaaaveyard.
A bit of stress hastens your steps. Halloween is here, and the Spirit of Halloween requires their bride. You expect another careful investigation leading to the next clue.
But upon arrival, you find less a clue than a clearly posted solution: a wide path stomped into the woods by large feet, strewn with chocolate wrappers and sparkly dildos.
You call the Spirit of Halloween—and the Halloweenland Beautification Committee to pick up the chocolate wrappers and sex toys—and set forth.
Twenty minutes later, behind a creepy caramel apple orchard, you find Detective Pumpkin herself. She's standing up from a cauldron, unwrapping herself from a string of blinking lights.
"Trick or Treaters!" Detective Pumpkin says, clearly relieved. "You're just in time. We have a mystery to solve."
No shit, you all think. That's what this whole community challenge is about. But before you can ask Detective Pumpkin what she's doing, the Spirit of Halloween appears in a whirl of bats and bonbons.
"My beloved!" the Spirit cries, and rushes forward.
When the public display of affection concludes, Detective Pumpkin asks, "What's wrong? Oh... oh dear. I lost track of time. It's not..."
"It's October 31st," the Spirit says. "Halloween, and the day of our wedding, yes. But that's not what matters. Are you all right? What happened?"
Detective Pumpkin sighs. "I was abducted by Cupid, Kinky the Smut Fairy, and seven hippos. It was all supposed to be very complicated. A multi-step mystery that would have taken our investigators several rounds of tags to solve. But they were still debating where to hide me, when they all vanished."
You recognize the names. Deities of the greatest, most sacred holidays of all: fanwork exchanges. A chill runs down your spines.
"The Great Archive has disappeared," Detective Pumpkin says, clutching the Spirit of Halloween's appendages. "My spooky darling..."
"I know," the Spirit of Halloween says, their voice hardening. "Today may be October 31, but our wedding will be on Halloween, and Halloween is whenever I say it is. I declare that Halloween is postponed until the mystery of the vanishing archive is solved, and every exchange returns to the land."
Overwhelmed by her darling Spirit's investigative spirit, Detective Pumpkin throws herself forward. The public display of affection resumes.
Happy October 31st, Trick or Treat community! Here's to a speedy AO3 restoration and rescheduled Halloween.
Your keen detective work leads you through the quaint pumpkin patches and spooky murder sheds of Halloweenland, to the (insert ominous music) graaaaaveyard.
A bit of stress hastens your steps. Halloween is here, and the Spirit of Halloween requires their bride. You expect another careful investigation leading to the next clue.
But upon arrival, you find less a clue than a clearly posted solution: a wide path stomped into the woods by large feet, strewn with chocolate wrappers and sparkly dildos.
You call the Spirit of Halloween—and the Halloweenland Beautification Committee to pick up the chocolate wrappers and sex toys—and set forth.
Twenty minutes later, behind a creepy caramel apple orchard, you find Detective Pumpkin herself. She's standing up from a cauldron, unwrapping herself from a string of blinking lights.
"Trick or Treaters!" Detective Pumpkin says, clearly relieved. "You're just in time. We have a mystery to solve."
No shit, you all think. That's what this whole community challenge is about. But before you can ask Detective Pumpkin what she's doing, the Spirit of Halloween appears in a whirl of bats and bonbons.
"My beloved!" the Spirit cries, and rushes forward.
When the public display of affection concludes, Detective Pumpkin asks, "What's wrong? Oh... oh dear. I lost track of time. It's not..."
"It's October 31st," the Spirit says. "Halloween, and the day of our wedding, yes. But that's not what matters. Are you all right? What happened?"
Detective Pumpkin sighs. "I was abducted by Cupid, Kinky the Smut Fairy, and seven hippos. It was all supposed to be very complicated. A multi-step mystery that would have taken our investigators several rounds of tags to solve. But they were still debating where to hide me, when they all vanished."
You recognize the names. Deities of the greatest, most sacred holidays of all: fanwork exchanges. A chill runs down your spines.
"The Great Archive has disappeared," Detective Pumpkin says, clutching the Spirit of Halloween's appendages. "My spooky darling..."
"I know," the Spirit of Halloween says, their voice hardening. "Today may be October 31, but our wedding will be on Halloween, and Halloween is whenever I say it is. I declare that Halloween is postponed until the mystery of the vanishing archive is solved, and every exchange returns to the land."
Overwhelmed by her darling Spirit's investigative spirit, Detective Pumpkin throws herself forward. The public display of affection resumes.
Happy October 31st, Trick or Treat community! Here's to a speedy AO3 restoration and rescheduled Halloween.
Per the OTW status page, AO3 is currently down for maintenance, projected to last two to four weeks.
Unfortunately, this makes Halloween work reveals impossible.
I'm currently pushing Trick or Treat dates back by about two weeks. Remaining pinch hits are due Nov 12, work reveals Nov 14, and creator reveals Nov 21.
However, we'll need a few days of functioning archive pre-reveals, so pinch hitters can post and so I can confirm everything is in. I'll post again on November 10 to confirm whether we're good to proceed or need to delay further.
Thank you to the assigned creators and pinch hitters who've left us in such good shape going into this delay. We won't have much scrambling to do once the archive is back :)
In the meantime...
- We have one more pinch hit available at the latest pinch hit post. Please claim this either logged-in to Dreamwidth or with a contact email so I can confirm your claim, and I'll assign them via AO3 when possible.
- Requests are still viewable via the handy auto app, so you can spend the extra time preparing treats!
- I believe one of the Community Challenge tags, Ghosts, had reached 20 works yesterday. So, I'll post an amended challenge update on the 31st :)
- If you have IRL plans to celebrate Halloween, please share in the comments below! Tell us about your costumes, your decorations, your sweet or spooky desserts.
One last thing...
Timely reveals are especially important for holiday exchanges. Since its first round in 2014, Trick or Treat has never delayed past Halloween. (*time zone dependent.) I've been proud to continue that track record since I took the gourdly crown in 2021. Through the tremendous efforts of pinch hitters—fellow participants, kindly strangers, friends I gently harass to help—our tricks and treats have always been ready on October 31.
I'm sad to break the streak this year, but that only highlights how impressive it is. Thank you, everyone, who's made that possible!
Unfortunately, this makes Halloween work reveals impossible.
I'm currently pushing Trick or Treat dates back by about two weeks. Remaining pinch hits are due Nov 12, work reveals Nov 14, and creator reveals Nov 21.
However, we'll need a few days of functioning archive pre-reveals, so pinch hitters can post and so I can confirm everything is in. I'll post again on November 10 to confirm whether we're good to proceed or need to delay further.
Thank you to the assigned creators and pinch hitters who've left us in such good shape going into this delay. We won't have much scrambling to do once the archive is back :)
In the meantime...
- We have one more pinch hit available at the latest pinch hit post. Please claim this either logged-in to Dreamwidth or with a contact email so I can confirm your claim, and I'll assign them via AO3 when possible.
- Requests are still viewable via the handy auto app, so you can spend the extra time preparing treats!
- I believe one of the Community Challenge tags, Ghosts, had reached 20 works yesterday. So, I'll post an amended challenge update on the 31st :)
- If you have IRL plans to celebrate Halloween, please share in the comments below! Tell us about your costumes, your decorations, your sweet or spooky desserts.
One last thing...
Timely reveals are especially important for holiday exchanges. Since its first round in 2014, Trick or Treat has never delayed past Halloween. (*time zone dependent.) I've been proud to continue that track record since I took the gourdly crown in 2021. Through the tremendous efforts of pinch hitters—fellow participants, kindly strangers, friends I gently harass to help—our tricks and treats have always been ready on October 31.
I'm sad to break the streak this year, but that only highlights how impressive it is. Thank you, everyone, who's made that possible!
Pinch Hits for Halloween Eve Eve Eve!
Oct. 28th, 2026 02:03 pmUPDATE OCT 29: AO3 is currently down for maintenance, and unfortunately may be down for some time. I'll update the community with a delay plan soon. In the meantime, pinch hits are still claimable, and you can browse the requests apps for treating while the archive is down.
---
There is a fresh batch of hits that must be pinched in order for our Halloween revels to proceed on time. Thank you so much to everyone who has pinch hit so far!
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve,and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
Please either comment logged-in or with a contact email so I can confirm you've got it. I'll officially assign claims when AO3 is back online.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
Pinch hits are dueOctober 30, November 12 [TBD when AO3 returns] 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
All claimed, thank you!!!
CLAIMED:
( Read more... )
---
There is a fresh batch of hits that must be pinched in order for our Halloween revels to proceed on time. Thank you so much to everyone who has pinch hit so far!
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve,
Please either comment logged-in or with a contact email so I can confirm you've got it. I'll officially assign claims when AO3 is back online.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
Pinch hits are due
All claimed, thank you!!!
CLAIMED:
( Read more... )
Excellent work, community detectives! You've reached 20+ works tagged Flowers or Costumes, and therefore finished interviewing makeup artist Nickelsmart and haberdasher Hellicent.
No need to continue to baker Catherine Catrina Catalina, because Hellicent has revealed that Detective Pumpkin never showed up for her suit-fitting.
Detective Pumpkin must have gone missing between the salon and the haberdashery. Please investigate the following local landmarks along the route to identify the crime scene.
***
To investigate, create a work with the tag assigned to that location. This can be your assignment or an extra treat for anyone whose requests lend themselves to the tag. To report your findings, post the work to the Trick or Treat 2026 collection. You may add the tag to applicable works you've already created.
Once a location's tag reaches 20 works, the Spirit of Halloween will review the evidence and announce the next step of the investigation.
The possible crime scenes are:
A local cemetery
Tag: Ghosts
A local Fall Festival
Tag: Carnival
A very very small local bookstore
Tag: Forced Proximity
See the community challenge introduction for more details.
No need to continue to baker Catherine Catrina Catalina, because Hellicent has revealed that Detective Pumpkin never showed up for her suit-fitting.
Detective Pumpkin must have gone missing between the salon and the haberdashery. Please investigate the following local landmarks along the route to identify the crime scene.
***
To investigate, create a work with the tag assigned to that location. This can be your assignment or an extra treat for anyone whose requests lend themselves to the tag. To report your findings, post the work to the Trick or Treat 2026 collection. You may add the tag to applicable works you've already created.
Once a location's tag reaches 20 works, the Spirit of Halloween will review the evidence and announce the next step of the investigation.
The possible crime scenes are:
A local cemetery
Tag: Ghosts
A local Fall Festival
Tag: Carnival
A very very small local bookstore
Tag: Forced Proximity
See the community challenge introduction for more details.
Post-Deadline Pinch Hits!!!! 🎃🎃🎃
Oct. 24th, 2026 12:09 pmThe deadline has passed, and pinch hits have arrived!
A community challenge update is pending, but that will come tomorrow-ish as I focus on pinch hits and other deadline matters first.
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
Pinch hits are due October 28, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
PH #52 (tokinokanatae):
ひゃくえむ。| Hyakuemu. | 100 Meters (2025), ポーの一族 | The Poe Clan (Manga), 名探偵コナン | Detective Conan | Case Closed
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2026/user/tokinokanatae
PH #53 (tryphaine):
The Thing from the Lake - Eleanor M. Ingram, Lucifer's Wife - Eleanor M. Ingram, The Game and the Candle - Eleanor M. Ingram
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2026/user/tryphaine
CLAIMED:
( Read more... )
A community challenge update is pending, but that will come tomorrow-ish as I focus on pinch hits and other deadline matters first.
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
Pinch hits are due October 28, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
PH #52 (tokinokanatae):
PH #53 (tryphaine):
CLAIMED:
( Read more... )
This is your reminder that assignments are due Saturday, October 24, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT)!
Please note there will be no extensions. If your internet tends to be unreliable, plan to submit with sufficient wiggle room.
Already finished? There are a few remaining pinch hits with an updated deadline at the latest pinch hit post!
And the community is very close to finishing the first investigation of this year's community challenge. The current tag tally is:
Costumes: 16
Flowers: 8
Knives: 10
See the latest challenge post for more details!
Please note there will be no extensions. If your internet tends to be unreliable, plan to submit with sufficient wiggle room.
Already finished? There are a few remaining pinch hits with an updated deadline at the latest pinch hit post!
And the community is very close to finishing the first investigation of this year's community challenge. The current tag tally is:
Costumes: 16
Flowers: 8
Knives: 10
See the latest challenge post for more details!
I Vant to Suck Your Pinch Hits!
Oct. 17th, 2026 11:45 pmOur previous batch of pinch hits is mostly gobbled up! We have a fresh plate of tasty assignments available for pinch hitting. Please peruse!
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
Claimed pinch hits as of Oct 22 are due at the regular assignment deadline, October 24, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
Update: Pinch Hits #5, 16, and 22 are due October 28, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
PH #5 (fulcrumania):
Kara no Kyoukai | The Garden of Sinners, Crossover Fandom, 殺戮の天使 | Satsuriku no Tenshi | Angels of Death - All Media Types, Fate/Grand Order
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2026/user/fulcrumania
PH #22 (IncurablePeppermint):
Star vs. the Forces of Evil, Alien Nine, SpongeBob SquarePants (Cartoon)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2026/user/IncurablePeppermint
CLAIMED:
( Read more... )
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
Claimed pinch hits as of Oct 22 are due at the regular assignment deadline, October 24, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
Update: Pinch Hits #5, 16, and 22 are due October 28, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
PH #5 (fulcrumania):
PH #22 (IncurablePeppermint):
CLAIMED:
( Read more... )
'tis a dark and stormy night when you arrive at Trick or Treat manor. Just there, mind you. The rest of the neighborhood has pretty clear skies. But furious stormclouds flit about the manor, reflecting the Spirit of Halloween's wrath. You're careful to keep the casefiles from getting wet.
(Review the case details and challenge format at this post.)
The weeping banshee housekeeper escorts you to the familiar parlor, where the Spirit of Halloween awaits.
The Spirit appears in many guises. A spooky witch or a ghostly clown or a slutty traffic cone. Whatever you think when you think "Halloween," that's how they appear to you.
But whatever their form, tonight, they're clutching a sensible tweed jacket that you last saw on Detective Pumpkin.
The Spirit wastes no time with pleasantries. "My fiancée went missing while running wedding errands," they explain. "I've found her schedule for the day. Please interview witnesses at each of these locations and report back."
They hand out the details, then return to hugging the tweed jacket and pacing back and forth. (Or floating back and forth, if you're imagining them as a sexy ghostly traffic cone.)
***
To investigate, create a work with the tag assigned to that location. This can be your assignment or an extra treat for anyone whose requests lend themselves to the tag. To report your findings, post the work to the Trick or Treat 2026 collection.
Once a location's tag reaches 20 works, the Spirit of Halloween will review the evidence and announce the next step of the investigation.
The possible last known sighting locations are:
Nickelsmart's Not Nasty Salon
Tag: Flowers
Hellicent's Haunted Haberdashery
Tag: Costumes
Cakes by Catherine Catrina Catalina the Cat
Tag: Knives
See the community challenge introduction for more details.
(Review the case details and challenge format at this post.)
The weeping banshee housekeeper escorts you to the familiar parlor, where the Spirit of Halloween awaits.
The Spirit appears in many guises. A spooky witch or a ghostly clown or a slutty traffic cone. Whatever you think when you think "Halloween," that's how they appear to you.
But whatever their form, tonight, they're clutching a sensible tweed jacket that you last saw on Detective Pumpkin.
The Spirit wastes no time with pleasantries. "My fiancée went missing while running wedding errands," they explain. "I've found her schedule for the day. Please interview witnesses at each of these locations and report back."
They hand out the details, then return to hugging the tweed jacket and pacing back and forth. (Or floating back and forth, if you're imagining them as a sexy ghostly traffic cone.)
***
To investigate, create a work with the tag assigned to that location. This can be your assignment or an extra treat for anyone whose requests lend themselves to the tag. To report your findings, post the work to the Trick or Treat 2026 collection.
Once a location's tag reaches 20 works, the Spirit of Halloween will review the evidence and announce the next step of the investigation.
The possible last known sighting locations are:
Nickelsmart's Not Nasty Salon
Tag: Flowers
Hellicent's Haunted Haberdashery
Tag: Costumes
Cakes by Catherine Catrina Catalina the Cat
Tag: Knives
See the community challenge introduction for more details.
Eek! It's the Pinch-less Hit-man!
Sep. 29th, 2026 09:25 pmThank you to everyone who has claimed our initial pinch hits! We have just a few lingering, and a batch of new pinch hits, as follows.
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
These are due at the regular assignment deadline, October 24, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
PH #5 (fulcrumania):
Kara no Kyoukai | The Garden of Sinners, Crossover Fandom, 殺戮の天使 | Satsuriku no Tenshi | Angels of Death - All Media Types, Fate/Grand Order
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2026/user/fulcrumania
PH #16 (oneiriad):
S&D Tier - Lighthouse Raiders (Web Series), No Rest For The Wicked (2026), Crossover Fandom, Original Work
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2026/user/oneiriad
ALREADY CLAIMED
( Read more... )
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
These are due at the regular assignment deadline, October 24, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
PH #5 (fulcrumania):
PH #16 (oneiriad):
ALREADY CLAIMED
( Read more... )
Community Challenge: A Wedding Mystery
Sep. 24th, 2026 07:51 pmOnce upon a time (two years ago), the Spirit of Halloween was murdered.
But they got better, thanks to the tireless work of Detective Pumpkin, with the aid of the trusty Trick or Treat Community.
The story ended with the resurrection of the Spirit of Halloween, the apprehension of the culprit Velmarina Vampire, and the culmination of the love story between the Spirit of Halloween and Detective Pumpkin.
(please review the 2024 Community Challenge posts for more detail: intro post, and October overview)
Detective Pumpkin and the Spirit of Halloween have spent the past two years in romantic bliss, enjoying all life's tricks and treats together. It was no surprise to anyone in Halloweenland when the wedding announcement arrived.
The wedding was scheduled for October 31, 2026, two years after the resurrection and love confession. And, dear Trick or Treat participant, this post should have been your invitation to the wedding.
But disaster has struck again.
Detective Pumpkin has been kidnapped.
You are once more tasked with solving a mystery. And if Detective Pumpkin is not returned by the wedding date, the Spirit of Halloween will make sure nobody can enjoy tricks and treats this spooky season.
Investigation Process
Solving the case requires three pieces of information:
- The last confirmed witness sighting
- The location of the crime scene
- The identity of the kidnapper
The Spirit of Halloween will conduct the preliminary investigation, and you will receive a set of three leads to investigate. The clues will be found in order -- you will find the last witness before unlocking leads about the crime scene, and you will find the crime scene before unlocking leads about the kidnapper.
You will investigate by creating works for the 2026 Trick or Treat collection, tagged with the correct tag for the lead you're investigating. Once you (collectively) post a certain number works for a lead, the Spirit of Halloween will review your investigation and report whether it's a real Clue or a Red Herring. Once you find the real clue, the next set of leads will unlock.
-----------------------
EXAMPLE YULETIDE INVESTIGATION:
*this is a fictional example. To my knowledge, the Spirit of Yuletide has not been murdered.
Detective Snowflake has narrowed down the crime scene to three possible locations in Dancing Hippo Tower.
The Snowy Forest
- Post 20 works tagged "Forest" to investigate
The Cozy Kitchen
- Post 20 works tagged "Cooking" to investigate
The Yule Mods' Secret Ritual Cavern
- Post 20 works tagged "Darkness" to investigate.
Participants reach 20 works tagged Darkness first. Detective Snowflake reviews the evidence and determines The Yule Mods' Secret Ritual Cavern is a Red Herring, so the investigation continues.
Participants next reach 20 works tagged "Forest," and Detective Snowflake reports that's the correct Clue. The crime scene has been found, so participants don't have to finish the third crime scene lead.
Detective Snowflake then reveals the next set of leads, to figure out the murder weapon, and the case continues along the same pattern.
-----------------------
The Spirit of Halloween will have the first set of leads ready on October 1. In the meantime, please ask any questions on this post, so we can clarify any procedural confusion in advance!
But they got better, thanks to the tireless work of Detective Pumpkin, with the aid of the trusty Trick or Treat Community.
The story ended with the resurrection of the Spirit of Halloween, the apprehension of the culprit Velmarina Vampire, and the culmination of the love story between the Spirit of Halloween and Detective Pumpkin.
(please review the 2024 Community Challenge posts for more detail: intro post, and October overview)
Detective Pumpkin and the Spirit of Halloween have spent the past two years in romantic bliss, enjoying all life's tricks and treats together. It was no surprise to anyone in Halloweenland when the wedding announcement arrived.
The wedding was scheduled for October 31, 2026, two years after the resurrection and love confession. And, dear Trick or Treat participant, this post should have been your invitation to the wedding.
But disaster has struck again.
Detective Pumpkin has been kidnapped.
You are once more tasked with solving a mystery. And if Detective Pumpkin is not returned by the wedding date, the Spirit of Halloween will make sure nobody can enjoy tricks and treats this spooky season.
Investigation Process
Solving the case requires three pieces of information:
- The last confirmed witness sighting
- The location of the crime scene
- The identity of the kidnapper
The Spirit of Halloween will conduct the preliminary investigation, and you will receive a set of three leads to investigate. The clues will be found in order -- you will find the last witness before unlocking leads about the crime scene, and you will find the crime scene before unlocking leads about the kidnapper.
You will investigate by creating works for the 2026 Trick or Treat collection, tagged with the correct tag for the lead you're investigating. Once you (collectively) post a certain number works for a lead, the Spirit of Halloween will review your investigation and report whether it's a real Clue or a Red Herring. Once you find the real clue, the next set of leads will unlock.
-----------------------
EXAMPLE YULETIDE INVESTIGATION:
*this is a fictional example. To my knowledge, the Spirit of Yuletide has not been murdered.
Detective Snowflake has narrowed down the crime scene to three possible locations in Dancing Hippo Tower.
The Snowy Forest
- Post 20 works tagged "Forest" to investigate
The Cozy Kitchen
- Post 20 works tagged "Cooking" to investigate
The Yule Mods' Secret Ritual Cavern
- Post 20 works tagged "Darkness" to investigate.
Participants reach 20 works tagged Darkness first. Detective Snowflake reviews the evidence and determines The Yule Mods' Secret Ritual Cavern is a Red Herring, so the investigation continues.
Participants next reach 20 works tagged "Forest," and Detective Snowflake reports that's the correct Clue. The crime scene has been found, so participants don't have to finish the third crime scene lead.
Detective Snowflake then reveals the next set of leads, to figure out the murder weapon, and the case continues along the same pattern.
-----------------------
The Spirit of Halloween will have the first set of leads ready on October 1. In the meantime, please ask any questions on this post, so we can clarify any procedural confusion in advance!
Boo! Assignments and Initial Pinch Hits!
Sep. 20th, 2026 07:08 pmAssignments are out! Please find yours at the email associated with your AO3 account. Alternatively, find it under the "Assignments" tab on the sidebar of your AO3 profile.
The community challenge post will be up this week—apologies for the delay.
Initial Pinch Hits
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
These are due at the regular assignment deadline, October 24, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
PH #5 (fulcrumania):
Kara no Kyoukai | The Garden of Sinners, Crossover Fandom, 殺戮の天使 | Satsuriku no Tenshi | Angels of Death - All Media Types, Fate/Grand Order
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2026/user/fulcrumania
PH #8 (redcandle17):
Camorra Chronicles - Cora Reilly, Born in Blood Mafia Chronicles - Cora Reilly, Wallflower Series - Lisa Kleypas
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2026/user/redcandle17
PH #9 (Sath):
Star Control (Video Games), Wolf Worm - T. Kingfisher, 重返未来: 1999 | Reverse: 1999 (Video Game)
https://autoao3app.fandom.tools/#/trickortreatex2026/user/Sath
CLAIMED
( Read more... )
- If you linked an unfinished letter, please try to complete and unlock it ASAP.
- If your recip's letter is incomplete or locked, please wait to contact me about it until after Sept 27. (Contacting me is optional. You're also welcome to just work from the signup details.)
- Assignments are due October 24, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT). Please note that there will be no extensions.
The community challenge post will be up this week—apologies for the delay.
Initial Pinch Hits
To claim, please comment on this post with your AO3 name and the number or name of the pinch hit you would like. Comments are screened. Pinch hits are first-come, first-serve, and if you're the first to claim, you'll receive the assignment to your email.
You don't have to be signed up to Trick or Treat to claim a pinch hit.
These are due at the regular assignment deadline, October 24, 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT).
PH #5 (fulcrumania):
PH #8 (redcandle17):
PH #9 (Sath):
CLAIMED
( Read more... )
Check your emails!
Sep. 18th, 2026 12:36 pmSignups are closed, and I've contacted several participants who were not matchable on offers. If your AO3 username begins with D, L, or S, please check the email associated with your AO3 account :)
edit: I've heard from everyone, thank you! Assignments will be out by Sept 21.
edit: I've heard from everyone, thank you! Assignments will be out by Sept 21.
Signups will close approximately 14.5 hours from time of posting, at 1:59 PM EDT/17:59 UTC on September 18.
Please visit the signup post for instructions and signup links!
If you've already signed up, please take the opportunity to review your signups for errors! Particularly requesting or offering the wrong media. That often spooks people :)
Please visit the signup post for instructions and signup links!
If you've already signed up, please take the opportunity to review your signups for errors! Particularly requesting or offering the wrong media. That often spooks people :)
Signups are now open! 🎃 They will close on September 18 at 1:59 PM EDT/17:59 UTC.
Please review the signup instructions in this post before signing up.
The community challenge post will be up sometime next week.
Signup form
Tagset
Requests summary
Signup summary
FAQ post
( Sign up details )
Please review the signup instructions in this post before signing up.
The community challenge post will be up sometime next week.
Signup form
Tagset
Requests summary
Signup summary
FAQ post
( Sign up details )
Nominations Clarifications Part 2!
Sep. 9th, 2026 02:35 pmTwo more days until signups open! I'm down to the final few pending nominations. Which means I have a few more questions for nominators below.
CHARACTER CLARIFICATIONS
Crossover Fandom
Ship: Sergei Kravinoff (Kraven the Hunter)/Tangerine (Bullet Train)/Reader
Please pick a fandom for Reader — Any Fandom? RPF?
イース | Ys (Video Games)
Is Bergar the same as Belger?
ALL MEDIA TYPES / RELATED FANDOMS / SERIES
Please choose a more specific version of the following fandoms.
Green Lantern - All Media Types
If this is for comics, should fall under DC (Comics).
Hunger Games Series - All Media Types
The books are already nominated separately as Hunger Games Trilogy - Suzanne Collins.
(I'll likely be combining the trilogy with the already-approved BOSAS as "Hunger Games Novels - Suzanne Collins," to handle the overlapping nominations there. Sorry for any confusion about the BOSAS approval.)
The Legend of Heroes: Trails Series
Trails into Reverie and Trails through Daybreak are already in.
RESOLVED
Twilight Series - All Media Types
Twilight Series - Stephenie Meyer is nominated separately.
Library of Ruina (Video Game)
Ship: Angela (Lobotomy Corporation)/Roland (Library of Ruina)
Ship: Angela/Binah (Lobotomy Corporation)
These characters are disambiguated with a different game in the series. How standalone are the installments—should these tags be moved to Crossover Fandom, or should the games be nominated as a series?
Or if Angela and Binah appear in Library of Ruina, I can just change the disambiguations.
CHARACTER CLARIFICATIONS
Crossover Fandom
Ship: Sergei Kravinoff (Kraven the Hunter)/Tangerine (Bullet Train)/Reader
Please pick a fandom for Reader — Any Fandom? RPF?
イース | Ys (Video Games)
Is Bergar the same as Belger?
ALL MEDIA TYPES / RELATED FANDOMS / SERIES
Please choose a more specific version of the following fandoms.
Green Lantern - All Media Types
If this is for comics, should fall under DC (Comics).
Hunger Games Series - All Media Types
The books are already nominated separately as Hunger Games Trilogy - Suzanne Collins.
(I'll likely be combining the trilogy with the already-approved BOSAS as "Hunger Games Novels - Suzanne Collins," to handle the overlapping nominations there. Sorry for any confusion about the BOSAS approval.)
The Legend of Heroes: Trails Series
Trails into Reverie and Trails through Daybreak are already in.
RESOLVED
Twilight Series - Stephenie Meyer is nominated separately.
Ship: Angela (Lobotomy Corporation)/Roland (Library of Ruina)
Ship: Angela/Binah (Lobotomy Corporation)
These characters are disambiguated with a different game in the series. How standalone are the installments—should these tags be moved to Crossover Fandom, or should the games be nominated as a series?
Or if Angela and Binah appear in Library of Ruina, I can just change the disambiguations.
Nominations close in about 12 hours! Please don't worry if your nominations haven't been processed yet—the upcoming three-day gap in the schedule is there for a reason.
In the meantime, I do have questions or requests regarding the following nominations!
CHARACTER CONFIRMATION QUESTIONS
イース | Ys (Video Games)
Can you confirm the existence of Bergar? I can't find them anywhere.
ALL MEDIA TYPES / RELATED FANDOMS / SERIES
Please choose a more specific version of the following fandoms.
Green Lantern - All Media Types
If this is for comics, should fall under DC (Comics).
Hunger Games Series - All Media Types
The books are already nominated separately as Hunger Games Trilogy - Suzanne Collins.
The Legend of Heroes: Trails Series
Trails into Reverie and Trails through Daybreak are already in
RESOLVED
The Magnus Archives (Podcast)
Elias Bouchard | Jonah Magnus
Jonathan "Jon" Sims | The Archivist
Michael | The Distortion
Fate/Grand Order
Ashiya Douman | Alter Ego
Asterios | Berserker
Fate/stay night (Visual Novel)
Ship: Archer (Heroic Spirit EMIYA)/Tohsaka Rin (F/sn VN)
Is Archer from a different canon? If so this should be nominated under crossovers.
Baby Corn Whisks to Whiskers
characters: 2 Dollar Bills, Baby Corn - Character, Corn, The Wind
Can you confirm whether all of these are characters, and which videos they appear in?
Dispatch (Video Game)
Blonde Blazer | Mandy (Dispatch)
Coupé | Janelle (Dispatch)
Golem | Bruno (Dispatch)
Invisigal | Courtney (Dispatch)
Robert Robertson | Mecha Man
Howl's Moving Castle - All Media Types
Howl Series - Diana Wynne Jones is already in.
Octopath Traveler Series (Video Games)
Octopath Traveler 0 and Octopath Traveler II are already in the tag set individually.
The Legend of Zelda & Related Fandoms
BOTW/TOTK is already nominated separately.
Andy Weir's Project Hail Mary - All Media Types
The book and movie are already in separately.
Star Wars Legends - All Media Types
Chronicles of Narnia - All Media Types
In the meantime, I do have questions or requests regarding the following nominations!
CHARACTER CONFIRMATION QUESTIONS
イース | Ys (Video Games)
Can you confirm the existence of Bergar? I can't find them anywhere.
ALL MEDIA TYPES / RELATED FANDOMS / SERIES
Please choose a more specific version of the following fandoms.
Green Lantern - All Media Types
If this is for comics, should fall under DC (Comics).
Hunger Games Series - All Media Types
The books are already nominated separately as Hunger Games Trilogy - Suzanne Collins.
The Legend of Heroes: Trails Series
Trails into Reverie and Trails through Daybreak are already in
RESOLVED
Elias Bouchard | Jonah Magnus
Jonathan "Jon" Sims | The Archivist
Michael | The Distortion
Ashiya Douman | Alter Ego
Asterios | Berserker
Ship: Archer (Heroic Spirit EMIYA)/Tohsaka Rin (F/sn VN)
Is Archer from a different canon? If so this should be nominated under crossovers.
characters: 2 Dollar Bills, Baby Corn - Character, Corn, The Wind
Can you confirm whether all of these are characters, and which videos they appear in?
Blonde Blazer | Mandy (Dispatch)
Coupé | Janelle (Dispatch)
Golem | Bruno (Dispatch)
Invisigal | Courtney (Dispatch)
Robert Robertson | Mecha Man
Howl Series - Diana Wynne Jones is already in.
Octopath Traveler 0 and Octopath Traveler II are already in the tag set individually.
BOTW/TOTK is already nominated separately.
The book and movie are already in separately.
Trick or Treat 2026 Nominations Open! 🎃
Sep. 1st, 2026 07:00 pmWelcome back to Trick or Treat! Nominations are open until September 8 at 17:59 UTC (1:59 PM EDT). Please read this post before nominating!
Countdown until nominations end.
Here is this year's tag set! You may nominate up to 8 fandoms with 8 characters or relationships in each.
Nominations format
You can nominate characters and/or relationships under each fandom you nominate. For AO3 matching algorithm reasons, both characters and relationships are nominated under the “Characters” slot in the tag set, and relationships should be specified by including “Ship:” in front of the pairing, whether romantic/sexual or platonic.
All fandoms in the tag set need to be nominated with at least one character or relationship tag under that fandom.
For all tags:
Please nominate original works under the fandom Original Work. If you don't specify a character's gender in the tag, you're leaving it up to the creator to choose.
Please avoid using pipes where possible and do not use diacritics/tone marks where unnecessary.
All character and ship nominations must be disambiguated. (See below for an explanation!)
Please use the name order as in the canon ("Given Name Family Name" for most western canons, "Family Name Given Name" for most Asian canons).
For relationship tags:
Relationships must include "Ship:" in front of the pairing.
You may nominate / or & relationships. "A/B" is a romantic or sexual relationship; "A & B" is a platonic relationship.
Please alphabetize ships by family name.
Please nominate crossovers under the fandom Crossover Fandom, with ships in the format:
Ship: Yuri Plisetsky (YOI) & Rajah (Aladdin).
You cannot nominate both / and & in a single tag. This means any nominations like "Ship: Aerith/Tifa & Cloud (FFVII)" will be rejected.
What is disambiguation?
This means adding the fandom in brackets after your nomination. Some examples:
Sakurayashiki Kaoru (SK8)
Leia Organa (SWOT)
Luke Skywalker (SWST)
Ship: Sherlock Holmes/John Watson (BBC Sherlock)
Ship: Sherlock Holmes/John Watson (Sherlock Holmes - ACD)
Ship: Mia Fey/Phoenix Wright (Ace Attorney)
Ship: Enoshima Junko/Tsumiki Mikan (DR Hope's Peak)
Ship: James "Bucky" Barnes & Steve Rogers (Marvel 616)
Before nominating, please check if your fandom is already in the tagset, and what disambiguations were used. Your nominations get approved faster if they are already in the correct format.
Specific Fandom Nomination Guidelines
All MCU movies and Marvel TV shows should be nominated under Marvel Cinematic Universe.
Dimension 20 campaigns should be nominated separately according to continuity.
Please nominate FFVII Remake/Rebirth separately from Compilation of FFVII.
Marvel Comics should be nominated by the characters' native universe, e.g. Marvel 616.
DC Comics should be nominated together under DCU (Comics). You may specify timeline (e.g. Pre-Flashpoint) in the disambiguation.
Arrowverse TV shows should be nominated together under DC's Arrowverse. Superman & Lois is separate.
All DCEU movies should be nominated together under DC Extended Universe.
Baldur's Gate games should be nominated together as Baldur's Gate (Video Games). "Tav" or "Dark Urge" are the main character of BG3. "Charname" is the main character of BG1 or 2. "Original Character(s)" are not player characters.
Buffyverse (TV) consists of the television shows for both Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV) and Angel: The Series.
Doctor Who is divided between 1963, 2005, and Torchwood.
Danganronpa has the original continuity ("Danganronpa - Hope’s Peak Arc") while Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony is separate.
Dragon Age should be nominated as Dragon Age - All Media Types.
Star Trek should be divided by show, with Star Trek: Alternate Original Series (Movies) separate.
Star Wars should be divided into Star Wars Prequel Trilogy, Star Wars Original Trilogy, Star Wars Sequel Trilogy, the standalone movies, then the individual properties, e.g. The Mandalorian (TV).
Ace Attorney and The Great Ace Attorney are two separate fandoms. Please use localized names where applicable, i.e, "Miles Edgeworth" and "Herlock Sholmes."
Countdown until nominations end.
Here is this year's tag set! You may nominate up to 8 fandoms with 8 characters or relationships in each.
Nominations format
You can nominate characters and/or relationships under each fandom you nominate. For AO3 matching algorithm reasons, both characters and relationships are nominated under the “Characters” slot in the tag set, and relationships should be specified by including “Ship:” in front of the pairing, whether romantic/sexual or platonic.
All fandoms in the tag set need to be nominated with at least one character or relationship tag under that fandom.
For all tags:
Please nominate original works under the fandom Original Work. If you don't specify a character's gender in the tag, you're leaving it up to the creator to choose.
Please avoid using pipes where possible and do not use diacritics/tone marks where unnecessary.
All character and ship nominations must be disambiguated. (See below for an explanation!)
Please use the name order as in the canon ("Given Name Family Name" for most western canons, "Family Name Given Name" for most Asian canons).
For relationship tags:
Relationships must include "Ship:" in front of the pairing.
You may nominate / or & relationships. "A/B" is a romantic or sexual relationship; "A & B" is a platonic relationship.
Please alphabetize ships by family name.
Please nominate crossovers under the fandom Crossover Fandom, with ships in the format:
Ship: Yuri Plisetsky (YOI) & Rajah (Aladdin).
You cannot nominate both / and & in a single tag. This means any nominations like "Ship: Aerith/Tifa & Cloud (FFVII)" will be rejected.
What is disambiguation?
This means adding the fandom in brackets after your nomination. Some examples:
Sakurayashiki Kaoru (SK8)
Leia Organa (SWOT)
Luke Skywalker (SWST)
Ship: Sherlock Holmes/John Watson (BBC Sherlock)
Ship: Sherlock Holmes/John Watson (Sherlock Holmes - ACD)
Ship: Mia Fey/Phoenix Wright (Ace Attorney)
Ship: Enoshima Junko/Tsumiki Mikan (DR Hope's Peak)
Ship: James "Bucky" Barnes & Steve Rogers (Marvel 616)
Before nominating, please check if your fandom is already in the tagset, and what disambiguations were used. Your nominations get approved faster if they are already in the correct format.
Specific Fandom Nomination Guidelines
All MCU movies and Marvel TV shows should be nominated under Marvel Cinematic Universe.
Dimension 20 campaigns should be nominated separately according to continuity.
Please nominate FFVII Remake/Rebirth separately from Compilation of FFVII.
Marvel Comics should be nominated by the characters' native universe, e.g. Marvel 616.
DC Comics should be nominated together under DCU (Comics). You may specify timeline (e.g. Pre-Flashpoint) in the disambiguation.
Arrowverse TV shows should be nominated together under DC's Arrowverse. Superman & Lois is separate.
All DCEU movies should be nominated together under DC Extended Universe.
Baldur's Gate games should be nominated together as Baldur's Gate (Video Games). "Tav" or "Dark Urge" are the main character of BG3. "Charname" is the main character of BG1 or 2. "Original Character(s)" are not player characters.
Buffyverse (TV) consists of the television shows for both Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV) and Angel: The Series.
Doctor Who is divided between 1963, 2005, and Torchwood.
Danganronpa has the original continuity ("Danganronpa - Hope’s Peak Arc") while Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony is separate.
Dragon Age should be nominated as Dragon Age - All Media Types.
Star Trek should be divided by show, with Star Trek: Alternate Original Series (Movies) separate.
Star Wars should be divided into Star Wars Prequel Trilogy, Star Wars Original Trilogy, Star Wars Sequel Trilogy, the standalone movies, then the individual properties, e.g. The Mandalorian (TV).
Ace Attorney and The Great Ace Attorney are two separate fandoms. Please use localized names where applicable, i.e, "Miles Edgeworth" and "Herlock Sholmes."
The masks are off! Creators are revealed!
Nov. 7th, 2025 09:20 amCreators are now revealed, and you can continue enjoying the collection here.
The final tally on the treat sheet was 79 out of the starting 225 -- that puts us just shy of reaching tier 2 (75 remaining). That's still a very good percentage, so cheers to the valiant treaters!
Thank you everyone for another wonderful Trick or Treat!
The final tally on the treat sheet was 79 out of the starting 225 -- that puts us just shy of reaching tier 2 (75 remaining). That's still a very good percentage, so cheers to the valiant treaters!
Thank you everyone for another wonderful Trick or Treat!